Hacker Newsnew | past | comments | ask | show | jobs | submitlogin

True, threading precedes conversations. But threading is not the same thing as Gmail-style conversations.

If you have a two messages that belong to one thread but that you put in two different folders, a thread-aware email client will still only show one message when you view it.

In a conversion-based email program however, there exists no such thing as an individual message. There are only whole conversations. When you view a 'single message', you always see the whole conversation regardless of the 'folder' it resides in. Basically, it always collects all the messages that belong to a thread even if you look at one single lonely message sitting in your inbox.

Persona seems to go a step further and not only collect threads into conversations, but also collect all conversations between a set of people into people-streams.



Okay. I understand what you meant now. I see this mostly as a consequence of tagging: since all the messages are in the same store, it makes sense to get messages from the same thread no matter the choice of tags you're viewing. I think it's true that Gmail was the first to do that.

[By the way, people are still busy porting these features back to native clients for power users. See http://sup.rubyforge.org/ and http://notmuchmail.org/.]




Guidelines | FAQ | Lists | API | Security | Legal | Apply to YC | Contact

Search: