Hacker Newsnew | past | comments | ask | show | jobs | submitlogin

Thanks

Homo economicus is real. Economics is useful and its really important (though imperfect) way f understanding the complex interactions between people all over the world.

The problem is that we are not homo economicus. We are Homo Sapiens. Europeans & Mexicans & Italians and Londoners. Some of us are even Americans. We are also brothers and lovers and criminals and parents.

Homo Economicus is a a description of a certain set of homo sapiens character traits.



Economics is useful, I never said the contrary, but how is homo economicus "real"?


@netcan allow me to disagree. People make part of their choices partially basing them on rational reasoning (and, even for that part, mostly based on incomplete data and often faulty logic). But just check what works in marketing and you'll see how limited that rationality really is.


I think we might be talking past each other.

I mean "exists" in a pretty weak sense. If you present people with complex economic choices, they make rational choices and maximise their economic utility. IE if they are using second hand computers running hacked up linux to play movies on their TV and a good, cheap alternative presents at a lower price, most will eventually switch to that.

Describing them as such allows us to predict their behaviour.


real in the sense that people make rational economic decisions. This is especially true when you see things aggregated.




Guidelines | FAQ | Lists | API | Security | Legal | Apply to YC | Contact

Search: