Hacker Newsnew | past | comments | ask | show | jobs | submitlogin

It's not "racially gated," lol. It's a word that was popularized and primarily used by black activists, just like how "bikeshed" as a verb was invented by and mainly used by software engineers.


Your comment boils down to "it's a black word appropriated by whites to use against minorities". Did I misunderstand? No? Then you are absolutely racially gating it.

As an aside, can you tell me a "white" word?

All language, through the history of humanity, morphs and changes over time. Just three decades ago we had this episode on must-see-TV night-

https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=jYmn3Gwn3oI

It was a perfectly cromulent, diagnostic, professional word to refer to someone delayed or slowed in development.

Now it's a heinous, instant-cancellation, offensive word.

Things change. As more and more people realized they could grift and make a career around being professionally woke, it took on negative meanings.


> Did I misunderstand?

Yes, and perhaps deliberately so, lol.

"Woke" was a word invented by black activists in the context of civil rights activism and is now being used disparagingly by people who are against modern forms of progressive activism. (I didn't use the word "white" once in the comments you're replying to, and you can CTRL+F me on that.)

I also think it's telling that a lot of people like to die on the hill of "retarded used to be a clinical term!" but far fewer people are willing to die on the hill of "mongoloid used to be a clinical term!", despite both being true in roughly the same context.


>I also think it's telling

What is it telling you? I feel like there is some big aha here that I am missing.

They both literally demonstrate the same thing -- the evolution of language -- albeit in different eras. "Mongoloid" had reverted to being considered disparaging if not clinically nonsensical by the late 70s. Retarded, literally meaning slowed, continued through to the 90s before the great cultural cancelling occurred. But both saw mainstream use that shifted to being cancelled (although everyone still chuckles when an Airbus implores the pilot to retard the plane), in the former case because it's nonsensical, and in the latter because we thought it just sounded too mean. That if we just impugned a word everything would be better.

No one is dying on a hill about that, and what a ridiculous way to frame it.

I love that people are busy running around down-arrowing every one of my comments, and hysterically clicking flag. Just yesterday I saw the same from the fanatical right. Get a grip.


> like how "bikeshed" as a verb was invented by and mainly used by software engineers

How dare you occupationally gate this term! (if it's not clear /s)


[flagged]


Oh, thank you for this rebuke kind sir!


Oh such a polite and wonderful retort! Love your thoughtful contribution! (/s)




Consider applying for YC's Fall 2026 batch! Applications are open till July 27.

Guidelines | FAQ | Lists | API | Security | Legal | Apply to YC | Contact

Search: