Hacker Newsnew | past | comments | ask | show | jobs | submitlogin

There is a famous saying here, for such people: " If someone tells you to jump in a well, would you? "

Voilent games can also be seen as a punching bag to vent out your anger, without hurting somebody in actual. It is not always the case that kids turn voilent in real life because of them. Parental guidance is needed at every step of life, blame poor parenting if you have to :?



Voilent games can also be seen as a punching bag to vent out your anger, without hurting somebody in actual.

It can also be seen as "practice" for people that are addicted to cruelty and dominance. I don't know about you, but when I play online I am often amazed at how low people can go, and how some never tire of being mean. And I'm not "raging" either, I can usually hold my own and generally care zilch about winning or loosing random pub games; but compared to how fun it is to play with "normal people", those sociopaths really do stick out, and it's obvious they live in a world where they have everything and all the peers they could want, and nothing that reminds them of the fact they have a problem - games and gamers don't do that usually, they're the silent accomplices.

But sure, if it keeps them from abusing animals or whatever, I'm all for it. But there's just no way of telling if it does that, or if it just grows a hunger for something more real. I don't feel comfortable shrugging it off. None of this can or should be solved with laws, it's all about debate and culture. It should be legal, but I frown upon it, and I want to be explicit and vocal about it and step on people's toes. Just because some got used to it, just because so many people do it, doesn't mean it's not fucking pathetic. But so are other things, movies for example. Not picking on violent video games, or violence... more the shallow display and glorification of it.


There is a famous saying here, for such people: " If someone tells you to jump in a well, would you? "

Bad example: I wouldn't but a lot of kids are easily influenced.

And no, I don't support a ban or censorship of games. I see this and guns as part of life, bad stuff happens some times, like when you cross the street and a car or a lightning might hit you.


True, the games should be in moderation as well, but I have seen numerous instances of negligence on part of parents. Your kid is 12, why let him play PG-13 games? A lot of people, need to be strict in this case.

this is indeed a very complex situation, like a algorithm, for which we know one of the 'possible answers' but not the answer as of yet.

On a second thought, I do think thats not the best possible example :/




Guidelines | FAQ | Lists | API | Security | Legal | Apply to YC | Contact

Search: